“God is imaginary”? Really?! Part 40: Understand Christian Motivations

When one questions motivations, you are questioning the reasons why someone believes something. And it’s fair to ask for reasons, but not fair to assume them, which is what occurs in “proof 40” from the website “God is imaginary“.

Mr. Brain starts off his proof with several bullet points:

Here is what we know about God:

  • There is no scientific evidence indicating that God exists. (see Proof #11) Which I’ve answered here
  • There is no scientific evidence indicating that God answers prayers. (see Proof #2Proof #41) —Demonstrated here and here that these are just bad arguments. 
  • If we set up an unambiguous situation — like asking God to restore amputated limbs — God never answers prayers. (see Proof #9) —Responded to here
  • The Bible is clearly the work of primitive men, not of an all-knowing supernatural being. (see Proof #13 and Proof #30) — And answered here and here
  • Etc. —Ditto.
So what’s left? Yet another straw man:
Yet, if you talk to actively practicing Christians, they ignore all of this evidence. They will tell you that God certainly does exist and that he is answering prayers for them every day. Christian bookstores and Christian magazines are filled with stories of answered prayers. Christians believe that God is reaching down out of heaven and answering billions of prayers on Earth for Christians.
As a Christian, as I’ve explained in these responses here and here, I do believe that God answers prayers, but to say that is the only reason, is just dishonest. I’m convinced by the reliability of the New Testament text, for reasons listed here; I am convinced by reasoned arguments such as the cosmological argument, the moral argument, and the teleological argument, I am convinced because of my overall experience as a believer, namely the regenerating power of the Holy Spirit. Even if God never answered a single prayer, there are good reasons to believe that God exists. Furthermore, as a philosopher, I am convinced by the nature of explanation. Also, as the Apostle Paul wrote,
 (What) can be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. For since the creation of the world his invisible attributes – his eternal power and divine nature – have been clearly seen, because they are understood through what has been made. So people are without excuse. For although they knew God, they did not glorify him as God or give him thanks, but they became futile in their thoughts and their senseless hearts were darkened. –Romans 1:19-21 NET
Mr. Brain also makes certain assumptions about the nature of life, something that I’ve responded to here, that he cannot explain, he just asserts them as facts without evidence.
He makes assertions about the will of God, which I’ve responded to here.
Marshall is very good at making assertions, even one such as this,
Is this a direct proof that God is imaginary? No. But it shows that Christians have strong incentives to delude themselves into believing. What you can see is that Christians — especially Christians who are members of church communities — have strong reasons to make up stories about prayer and to ignore all the evidence that “answered prayers” really are coincidences. These motivations completely explain the phenomenon of “answered prayers” in Christian communities.
I’ve answered his accusation here and here, but something worthy of consideration is this presentation by Craig Keener, where he discusses the nature of miracles and answered prayer.
A Christian is ultimately motivated by evidence that is greater ins cope and complexity that can ever be discussed in a blog article, it has to be lived out. That may seem like a cop-out response, but it is hard to put it in words because the motivation isn’t based in what a believer can gain in this life, but in love, and one cannot truly love something that is “imaginary”.


  1. Really good answer to such a stupid “PROOF”.


    You link to such a stupid website in your high authority website.

    It will eventually increase rank of it on Google.

    Because Google see authority by PageRank which is mainly on Backlinks and Anchor Text on other relavent and quality site.

    Many website by mistakely link to this site and now we see that it rank well in Google and attract many visitor.

    By ranking good, it has too many visitor and traffic which eventually increase click on ads and impression on ads of that site and increase revenue of that site.

    That attract more people and this process will be continuing.

    So, I request you to

    Remove link of Site and anchor text.

    Please remove anchor text and just mentione name godisimaginary.com without linking to this site.

    This is to support high quality and authority site instead of such a stupid site.

Leave a Reply to Mahakadev Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s